Introduction

In contrast to the commonly held belief that hedge fund performance is entirely reliant on the skill of the manager, a significant factor influencing the performance of hedge fund managers is the macroeconomic cycle.

In this article, we aim to explore this relationship, shedding light on the extent to which economic fluctuations influence hedge fund managers’ outcomes. We focus on a specific hedge fund strategy, the Commodity Trading Advisor (CTA), and analyze its performance during distinct macroeconomic cycles over the past two decades.

CTA hedge funds engage in trading commodities and derivative contracts across various markets. These funds often utilize systematic, quantitative approaches to capitalize on trends, manage risk, and generate returns. Traditionally, CTAs have provided their investors with an effective hedging tool against crisis periods [1]. To test this theory, we use the monthly time series of the Barclay CTA Index [2] as a benchmark for this hedge fund strategy.

Selecting Macroeconomic Cycles: Insights from NBER's Turning Points

To delve into the impact of macroeconomic cycles on CTA hedge fund performance, we have used the insight provided by the National Bureau of Economic Research (NBER) [3]. NBER's chronology of economic cycles serves as our guiding star, allowing us to pinpoint pivotal turning points that mark significant shifts in economic conditions.  •    December 2007: the Onset of the Great Recession,
  •    June 2009: Emergence from the Great Recession,
  •    February 2020: the COVID-19 Recession,
  •    and April 2020: the Dawn of a New Economic Expansion.

To unravel the intricate relationship between macroeconomic cycles and CTA performance, we focus on three distinct periods:

  1.    December 2007 to June 2009 - The Great Recession and Recovery
  2.    June 2009 to February 2020 - Post-Recession Prosperity and Pre-Pandemic Tranquillity
  3.    February 2020 to Present - We split this period into two sub-periods:
     3-1.     February 2020 to February 2022: Pandemic and the Outbreak of Russia-Ukraine Conflict
     3-2.     February 2022 to July 2023: Emergence of a New High Yield Environment

Results: Quantifying the Impact

Utilizing AlternativeSoft’s analytical platform, we investigated different statistics of the selected CTA index over the three distinct economic periods. Then we compared the performance of CTAs against the S&P500 index. Instead of solely using return and outperformance statistics, we have focused on risk-adjusted return metrics including Jensen’s Alpha and Sharpe ratio. This way we will be able to capture the differences between different periods more effectively. Table 1 summarizes the results of the analysis.


Macroeconomic Cycle

Phase

Annual Jensen Alpha vs S&P500

Annual Sharpe Ratio

Annual Outperformance vs S&P500

December 2007 - June 2009

Global Financial Crisis

4.40%

1.05

34.86%

June 2009 - February 2020

Stable Economy / Low Yield Environment

-0.66%

0.03

-11.75%

February 2020 - July 2023

Covid and Russia-Ukraine Conflict

5.86%

1.77

-15.19%

High Yield Period

1.10%

0.23

0.68%

Table 1: Hedge Fund Managers’ Performance over Different Macroeconomic Phases [4]

The results of the research have been listed as follows:  •    During the Global Financial Crisis, particularly when the markets crashed rapidly, CTAs significantly outperformed any other investment strategy based on both risk-adjusted and pure return metrics. During the first period of the analysis, the CTAs not only outperformed the US equity market by over 34% on an annual basis (the cumulative returns are presented in Figure 1), but they also created an alpha of annual 4.40% over the S&P500. The added value is also evident by considering the Sharpe ratio of the CTA index over the period. These managers provided their investors with 1.05 units of reward for every unit of risk. During crisis periods correlation amongst all markets increases substantially [5] and the CTA managers have access to new sources of return. Highly liquid futures contracts allow CTA managers the flexibility to incorporate a wide range of investment strategies. These funds have traditionally demonstrated natural positive skewness that has been useful during stressed markets [6].  •    The CTA’s performance changes when the nature of the crisis changes. When it comes to the next crisis period, marked as Covid and the Outbreak of the Russia-Ukraine Conflict in Table 1, which inherently was a supply chain crisis rather than a financial crisis, the CTAs have underperformed the equity market based on pure return metrics. However, after adjusting the returns for the risks, the CTAs have created again a significant alpha and an acceptable Sharpe ratio. One reason for acceptable results of the CTAs during this period using the risk-adjusted metrics could be the significant fluctuations the equity markets were experiencing throughout the period.

Figure 1: Cumulative Returns of the CTA Index and S&P500 Index from Dec 2007 – July 2023

Figure 1: Cumulative Returns of the CTA Index and S&P500 Index from Dec 2007 – July 2023
Source: AlternativeSoft software

  •    CTAs generally do not perform well during normal courses of the economy. Over the second period of the analysis, the CTAs underperformed the equity market based on both return and risk-adjusted metrics. All criteria in this period show the underperformance of the CTAs when the economy was experiencing a long period of stability and low-interest rate and a disinflationary period.  •    Traditionally, commodity markets are recognized for their ability to provide a natural hedge against inflation. It is claimed that CTAs have the skill and resources to invest in various types of commodity contracts and more importantly they can leverage their investments using margin trading. However, contrary to this belief, the result of this research shows that during the recent inflationary period, these managers have not managed to provide a hedge against inflation. Over this period, investors could have achieved much better results if they had directly invested in the commodity contract itself. One possible reason for the CTA's underperformance could be attributed to the end of the cheap money after significant recent rises in interest rates, from near to zero territory to rates higher than 5%. In the new high-yield environment, every strategy will be evaluated against much higher risk-free rates, and creating a real alpha against the equity market will not be an easy task.  •    The findings of this research suggest that the traditional role of CTAs is gradually changing over time. The CTAs are not simply a winning strategy during hard times. Every economic phase should be studied independently, and the most suitable strategy should be performed depending on the nature of the crisis and the alternative strategies.

Conclusion

As we examine the economic landscape of the past two decades, we gather important insights about the role of CTA hedge funds in this ever-evolving environment. Our analysis indicates that while CTAs have traditionally acted as effective safeguards for investors during times of crisis, this role is gradually evolving. The period of easy access to low-cost capital has ended, prompting a need to reconsider the use of CTA strategies as a response to downturns or crises. In the new high yield setting, every strategy must now be assessed against significantly higher risk-free benchmarks, making it more challenging to achieve substantial gains compared to the equity market. On a contrasting note, the rise of the AI revolution and the subsequent growth in tech company returns have enhanced the appeal of equity markets. Consequently, surpassing the performance of these markets requires more informed and discerning investment decision-making.

References

[1] https://www.alternativesoft.com/applied-research/cta-hedge-funds-when-is-the-right-time-to-enter.html

[2] Source: BarclayHedge

[3] This organization is responsible for dating business cycles in the United States, providing a comprehensive framework for our analysis.

[4] Dynamic risk-free rates of LIBOR and SOFR (after it replaced LIBOR) have been used for the analysis of Sharpe Ratio and Jensen’s Alpha.

[5] https://www.alternativesoft.com/hedge-fund-portfolio-diversification-during-crisis.html

[6] https://www.alternativesoft.com/applied-research/russia-ukraine-conflict-has-it-changed-the-performance-of-hedge-funds.html

N.B. This article does not constitute any professional investment advice or recommendations to buy, sell, or hold any investments or investment products of any kind, and should be treated as more of an illustrative piece for educational purposes.