2022 has been an extraordinary year thus far for financial assets. USA inflation rates peaked at 9.06%, the highest it has been in 41 years [1]. Both the equity market and fixed-income markets have experienced their second most negative year-to-date returns after the global financial crisis[2] . 30-Year average fixed mortgage rates in the United States hit 6.9% in September, the highest since the US housing market crash of 2008 [3] . The economy, still not fully recovered from the negative effects of COVID, is now facing the effects of a global energy crisis and war. In light of this geo-political turbulence, some analysts suggested markets will witness an end to the stability of financial systems over a relatively long period [4] . Financial market professionals are questioning whether hedge fund managers have enough experience to weather the storm. The hypothesis is that those funds whose managers have experienced previous crisis periods will perform better throughout the new crisis period.

Defining Manager Experience

Using AlternativeSoft’s analytical platform, we compared the performance of two samples of hedge funds [5] during the last 9 months from the start of 2022. The first sample included funds whose current manager start date was before 2005 - meaning these funds had experienced a previous high-interest rate environment and the 2008 global financial crisis under the same managers. The second sample included the funds whose current managers started their asset management after 2017; a period of recovery after the global financial crisis and the emergence of a new era of near-to-zero real interest rates. Two equally weighted portfolios were constructed [6] and the performance of these two portfolios was compared based on their annualized alpha.

Results

The result of this analysis indicates a considerable outperformance of the portfolio of funds with a long history of asset managers. Those funds whose manager start date was before 2005, created 9.18% alpha (annualized) during the first 9 months of 2022 against funds with newer manager start dates.

The risk and return statistics of the portfolios and their comparison with the sector index are shown in Table 1:

Statistics
(9-month period from
Jan 2022 to Sept 2022)
Managers
who started
before 2005
Managers
who started
after 2017
BarclayHedge
Hedge Fund
Index
Annualized Return 2.88%
-15.97%
-15.43%
Annualized Volatility 6.47%
8.81%
7.65%
Skewness 1.07 -0.72 0.34
Annual Sharpe Ratio
(Rf = SONIA)
0.30 -1.92 -2.14
Annual Sortino Ratio
(Vs 0%)
0.89 -1.71 -1.91
Max Drawdown -3.51% -12.23% -11.81%
Table 1: Risk and Return Comparison of baskets of funds during Jan 2022 to Sep 2022

The more experienced fund managers have outperformed both the less experienced managers and the sector index based on all selected return and risk metrics. These managers exhibit higher returns and lower volatilities during the last 9 months; thus, creating considerably higher rewards for every unit of the risk they take when their performance is compared with the other portfolio and the index. Their Sortino ratio is higher meaning the portfolio is operating efficiently and avoiding unnecessary risks that are not being rewarded in the form of higher returns. The more experienced managers have also achieved a positive skewness compared to the negative skewness for the same period for less experienced managers.

Survivorship Bias?

It should however be noted that this extraordinary outperformance might represent a survivorship bias. To remove it, a second analysis investigating the general relationship between a sample of hedge funds’ performance and their manager’s experience (at the same fund) is required to ascertain whether the more experienced managers truly create higher alphas.

The Second Analysis

For the second piece of analysis, the fund managers’ start date has been used as a proxy for the managers’ experience [7]. The aim is to see if these funds have performed well during the new crisis period from the start of the year, with all inflationary factors in place.

To investigate this relationship, a four-step process is conducted as follows using the AlternativeSoft analytical platform:

1. 500 hedge funds were randomly selected.
2. The hedge fund managers’ experience was calculated based on the number of years they have been with the fund.
3. For each fund the annualized alpha was calculated against the sector performance from the start of the year. The index used as a proxy for the sector was the BarclayHedge Hedge Fund Index.
4. The funds are ranked by annualized alpha and split into deciles.

The results show that the top decile (top 10% best performing) funds are on average around 3 years and 8 months more experienced than the worst decile. The highest rank has 15.67 years of experience on average. This is the highest average amongst all groups. To test the significance of this difference a t-test [8] analysis was conducted on the difference between the means of the top and bottom deciles. The t-test result shows that the difference between the performance of the highest and the lowest ranks is statistically significant.

Relationship between Manager Experience and Strategy

AlternativeSoft was used to check if there is a relationship between manager experience and alpha generation capabilities per strategy. The Annualized Alpha against the BarclayHedge Hedge Fund Index for each strategy from Jan 2022 to Sep 2022 is plotted in chart 1. While the top two best-performing strategies in terms of Alpha were CTA and Macro there is not enough evidence to suggest this was due to the experience of the managers.

Chart 1: Hedge Funds Average Annualized Alpha and Manager Experience Based on Different Strategies
Chart 1: Hedge Funds Average Annualized Alpha and Manager Experience Based on Different Strategies

Conclusion

AlternativeSoft’s analysis shows that from the beginning of 2022, an equally weighted portfolio of hedge funds whose managers had experienced the financial crisis of 2007-2009, considerably outperforms the funds whose managers did not. Investigating the general relationship between hedge funds’ performance and their managers' start dates only shows a significant difference between extreme performances. The top 10% of the best-performing hedge funds based on their alphas during 2022 benefit from on average 3 years and 8 months more experience than the worst 10%. The results of a t-test for the difference in the performance of the two deciles indicate that this difference is statistically significant.

This research might have been impacted by two limitations. Firstly, the possibility of survivorship bias in comparing the performance of the two equally weighted portfolios, meaning that the funds with a long history of consistent managers that are still active are the most successful sample of funds. A possible survivorship bias of this analysis has been removed by conducting the second analysis which investigates the relationship between hedge funds’ performance and their managers' start dates for a randomly selected universe of funds. The second limitation is that an earlier manager start date does not necessarily translate into more experience. This limitation could be addressed in future studies.

References

[1] Based on FRED Economic Database.

[2] The proxies used for the market are the S&P500 and the Eurekahedge Fixed Income Index.

[3] https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/MORTGAGE30US

[4] https://www.economist.com/leaders/2022/10/06/a-new-macroeconomic-era-is-emerging-what-will-it-look-like

[5]Morningstar database is used

[6]Using a feature of AlternativeSoft called Portfolio-Linked-Asset (PLA)

[7]Using Morningstar databased

[8]The null hypothesis is that the means of the two samples (the top and bottom deciles) are not statistically different. A two-tailed t-test was performed with a confidence level of 95%.

N.B. This article does not constitute any professional investment advice or recommendations to buy, sell, or hold any investments or investment products of any kind, and should be treated as more of an illustrative piece for educational purposes.