Introduction

Although the federal reserve has not yet announced a recession, the U.S. economy has slowed significantly in terms of the rate of real GDP growth compared to the previous year. Lower disposable income and higher interest rates are respectively reflected in lower spending and weakening housing sector activity. Upward inflation is reflecting boosted energy and food prices induced by the Russia-Ukraine war and supply chain disruptions due to Covid. Recent indicators also point to the fact that the 2023 macroeconomic outlook remains uncertain and fragile. The forecast for real GDP growth stands at just 0.5 percent in 2023 well below the estimate of the longer-run GDP growth rate. Inflation rates are significantly above the federal reserve’s target inflation rate, and interest rates were increased again by the Federal Open Market Committee (FOMC) by 50 basis points at their latest meeting in December. However, this increase is effectively slowing down from the 0.75% increase experienced in the June, July, September, and November meetings, and the job market is also experiencing good conditions, with the unemployment rate near its record low levels[1]. Will hedge funds be able to withstand these macroeconomic challenges? What would be the most vulnerable and the most resilient strategies in the hard times? What factors will mostly affect hedge funds’ ability to execute their strategy?

Research Outline

We conducted a stress test analysis using AlternativeSoft’s quantitative analytical platform to investigate the impact of macroeconomic factors on selected hedge funds. The aim is to identify the most vulnerable and the most resilient strategies under different scenarios. The scenarios are influenced by the federal reserve’s predictions for 2023. The Baseline Scenario is based on the published forecasts of the Federal Open Market Committee held in December 2022.

Proxies for Hedge Funds’ Strategies

This research uses 12 different BarclayHedge indices as proxies for each hedge fund strategy. The indices include the BarclayHedge CTA, Distressed Securities, Fixed Income Arbitrage, Global Macro, Equity Market Neutral, Multi-Strategy, Emerging Markets, Equity Long/Short, Technology, Merger Arbitrage, Event Driven, Equity Long Bias Indices.

Defining the Stress Test Factors

Economic cycles affect both available income for investment and the dynamics of financial markets. Recessions and tighter financial conditions cause hedge fund managers to reduce the number of exposures to different asset classes and their portfolio allocations [2]. Therefore, the US real GDP Growth Rate [3] and Unemployment Rate are selected as factors representing the economic cycle for our stress testing analysis.
The inflation rate is the third factor selected for this research. The US monthly PCE Price Index [5] is selected to address the inflation rate.
Some hedge fund products may not be able to withstand an increase in interest rates. So, this item is also selected as one of the stress testing factors. Interest rates in this research are represented by the Federal Funds Effective Rate[6].

Scenarios Definition

The following three scenarios are defined to conduct the stress test:     •  The Baseline Scenario is forecasted by the federal reserve for 2023.
    •  The Target Scenario is a long-run fed target.
    •  And the Worst-Case Scenario is equivalent to the worst record during the last 5 years.

Table 1 represents the values of the selected macroeconomic factors for 2023 under three defined scenarios.

Factor Baseline Scenario Target Scenario Worst Case Scenario
Real GDP Growth 0.50% 1.80% -1.50%
Unemployment Rate 4.60% 4.00% 6.80%
PCE Inflation Rate 3.10% 2.00% 5.70%
Fed Funds Rate 5.10% 2.50% 5.63%
Table 1: Values of Selected Macroeconomic Factors in 2023 under the Defined Scenarios.

Stress Testing

Using AlternativeSoft’s Stress Testing Module, we simulated the expected annual return of each hedge fund strategy during the scenarios defined above. Table 2 displays the results - sorted by returns under the Worst-Case scenario.

Strategy Annualized Stressed Returns
Baseline Scenario Target Scenario Worst Case Scenario
1 CTA 9.76% 8.20% 17.35%
2 Distressed Securities 9.60% 10.85% 9.66%
3 Fixed Income Arbitrage 7.86% 8.38% 4.60%
4 Global Macro 3.81% 6.90% 3.04%
5 Equity Market Neutral 3.68% 3.92% 2.60%
6 Multi-Strategy 7.46% 8.75% 0.30%
7 Emerging Markets 8.99% 11.79% -1.32%
8 Equity Long/Short 5.80% 8.63% -1.59%
9 Technology 5.10% 9.76% -2.38%
10 Merger Arbitrage 4.75% 6.83% -4.81%
11 Event Driven 5.35% 8.36% -7.12%
12 Equity Long Bias 3.48% 10.22% -12.22%
Table 2: Stressed Returns for Hedge Fund Strategies under the Defined Scenarios

The results show that the most resilient hedge fund strategy under all three scenarios is CTA. This result is supported by several studies. Highly liquid futures contracts allow CTA managers the flexibility to incorporate a wide range of investment strategies. These funds have traditionally demonstrated natural positive skewness that has been useful during stressed markets [7]. According to AlternativeSoft’s previous pieces of research, CTAs have been the winning strategy during the previously stressed markets including 2008 [8] and the Ukraine-Russia crisis [9].

Chart 1: Stressed Returns for Hedge Fund strategies under the defined scenarios

On the other hand, Equity long-bias and long-only strategies cannot withstand macroeconomic pressure. The Even Driven strategy would also be suffering under our most pessimistic forecast about the future. This might be caused by the fact that during stressful macroeconomic conditions, fund managers decrease their market exposures, irrespective of their fundamental characteristics. They minimize their systematic risk and therefore they cannot take the reward they normally could. The Event-Driven strategy takes positions in corporate securities to benefit from M&As, re-organizations, capital restructuring, and so on mostly using leverages. Both unstable economic conditions and an increasing trend of cost of leverage (interest rates) could potentially cause the underperformance of the Event-Driven strategy. The same logic applies to the Merger Arbitrage strategy implying that a systemic risk caused by a macroeconomic period of stress could erode any benefits that would have been accessible in a normal course of the economy.

Conclusion

In this research, a stress test was conducted to investigate the most resilient selected hedge fund strategies under defined scenarios. The results suggest that the most outperforming strategy under pressure (the Worst-Case Scenario) is the CTA. This is supported by previous research conducted by AlternativeSoft. On the other hand, Equity Long Bias and Event Driven hedge fund products are not able to withstand our stressed macroeconomic conditions. The Long Bias strategy is the most vulnerable under the Worst-Case Scenario, contrary to the fact that our research suggests that this strategy would perform acceptably under the two other scenarios. This research solely considers the effects of macroeconomic factors on hedge funds’ performance. However, some analysts suggest that factors related to financial assets and commodity asset classes might be more common during difficult conditions. They claim falling stock markets may be harsher than recessions for hedge funds. Considering these empirical studies, we recommend investigating market factors for future stress testing analysis.

References

[1] https://www.federalreserve.gov/newsevents.htm

[2] Stafylas, D., Anderson, K., & Uddin, M. (2018). Hedge fund performance attribution under various market conditions. International Review of Financial Analysis, 56, 221-237. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.irfa.2018.01.006

[3] https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/GDPC1

[4] https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/UNRATE

[5] https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/PCEPILFE

[6] https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/FEDFUNDS

[7][2] H. H. Lean, K. F. Phoon, and W.-K. Wong, “Stochastic dominance analysis of CTA funds,” Rev. Quant. Finance Account., vol. 40, no. 1, pp. 155–170, 2013.

[8] CTA Hedge Funds: When Is the Right Time to Enter? A Comparison of Momentum and Contrarian Strategies

[9]Russia-Ukraine Conflict: Has it Changed the Performance of Hedge Funds?

[10] https://hull-repository.worktribe.com/OutputFile/3218045

[11]Stafylas, D., Anderson, K., & Uddin, M. (2018). Hedge fund performance attribution under various market conditions. International Review of Financial Analysis, 56, 221-237. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.irfa.2018.01.006

N.B. This article does not constitute any professional investment advice or recommendations to buy, sell, or hold any investments or investment products of any kind, and should be treated as more of an illustrative piece for educational purposes.